Parliamentary Debate on Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill: First Reading Highlights

In a recent parliamentary session, MPs engaged in procedural discussions during the first reading of the Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill. The debate focused on voting procedures and conduct within the House of Representatives.

Personal Voting Rights Request by Green Party

Chloe Swarbrick, Co-Leader of the Green Party, called for a personal vote on the bill under Standing Order 142. She emphasized that Green MPs would be allowed to vote according to their conscience without being whipped by the party. Speaker Trevor Mallard clarified that such requests must be made prior to casting the party vote and explained that this procedural rule has been clear since 1996. He reiterated that a personal vote cannot be requested retrospectively.

Conduct in Parliament

Hon David Seymour, Associate Minister of Justice, raised concerns about members' conduct by moving out of their seats during proceedings. He suggested that others involved in similar actions might also warrant naming for grossly disorderly conduct. Speaker Mallard advised that potential breaches of privilege should be addressed through formal communication rather than immediate action during sessions. He emphasized that naming is reserved for clear instigators of disorder and should not be taken lightly.

Voting Outcome on Committee Referral

The session concluded with a vote on referring the bill to the Justice Committee. The motion was agreed upon, with 68 Ayes (New Zealand National: 49; ACT New Zealand: 11; New Zealand First: 8) and 54 Noes (New Zealand Labour: 34; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand: 15; Te Pāti Māori: 5). An initial miscount was corrected from 55 No votes to 54.

Conclusion

The debate highlighted important aspects of parliamentary procedure, including voting rights and maintaining decorum. The discussions underscored the balance between party discipline and individual conscience, as well as the importance of adhering to established rules within Parliament.